Two
weeks ago, the latest district of The Avenues mall’s ambitious Phase 3 expansion
opened: Prestige. It’s a two-story boulevard packed with luxury retail stores and
a few expensive restaurants. And to make absolutely sure that no one would miss
the fact that Prestige was ‘luxurious’ and ‘expensive’ the designers seemingly
painted half its surfaces in gold. Centering the boulevard is an elegant
circular fountain, surrounded with a bed of blood-red flowers. The fountain sits
under a weird yet impressive "23m high central dome" that screams for attention; so much
so that its lights continuously change color to entertain its bedazzled viewers.
The central dome and fountain |
The dome displaying different colors |
Some parts of Prestige are truly beautiful, especially in the morning, when the undulating skylights splash the whole space with natural light; but it still makes me uneasy. Perhaps the best way to explain my uneasiness is by comparing Prestige with a McBurger. The sight of a McBurger is mouth-watering, its smell is seductive, its taste is delicious, and it’s shockingly economical. But even if you can’t easily tell it apart from an organic home-cooked healthy burger, it’s still junk food.
Prestige
is the same: it does many things right, but for the wrong reasons. It wants to
impress rather than serve its visitors, it shows-off rather than celebrate its architecture.
Its McArchitecture.
First floor corridor |
An
example of this is the lack of seating around the boulevard’s centerpiece: the
dome and fountain. Twice I have been there, and twice I have seen people
standing around the fountain taking pictures of it and the dome; and yet there’s
no place for them sit and enjoy the view. I actually tried sitting on the border
of the fountain’s flower bed, naively thinking it was a disguised bench, but
was quickly notified by one of black-suited red-tied guards that it was not for
sitting on; unfortunately it was not designed for human interaction, but only
to be admired from a distance.
Another
example is to simply quote how The Avenues website describes Prestige’s design:
“A combination of rich materials reinforces exclusivity with public spaces indulging the senses and providing a lavish platform for some of the world’s most exclusive brands”. But there isn’t and shouldn’t be anything ‘exclusive’ about a mall; it’s
supposed to be extremely inclusive. Rather than reinforcing class difference, the
design of Prestige could’ve encouraged mass hospitality and equality, despite
being home for expensive retail stores.
Armani Cafe' seating |
Although
Prestige does fulfill its main objective of evoking ideas of luxury and
extravagance, it’s trying too hard to achieve that goal, to the point that it
risks being vulgar. There’s a difference between actual quality and simple
appearance, and Prestige pays too much attention to the latter. This is not to
say that Prestige has no quality, not at all, but that with the same exaggerated
effort spent on making the place feel ‘luxurious’, Prestige’s designers and
developers could’ve invested their time in creating a dearly needed enjoyable,
warm, and inclusive public space.
View from first floor |
No comments:
Post a Comment